TL;DR

Ohioans above 400% of the poverty level, about $63,840 for one person or $132,000 for four, get no premium tax credit for 2027. Rates rise about 16.3% on average after 19.8% for 2026, and CareSource is leaving the individual market, which sends more than 28,000 people shopping. There is no single right move. A healthy single freelancer, a couple whose carrier is leaving, and a family with one ongoing condition should each end up in a different place.

Advice about the subsidy cliff tends to be written as if every household above the line were the same. They are not, and Ohio's 2027 market makes the differences matter more. Marketplace enrollment here has already dropped from more than 583,000 in 2025 to 469,616 in 2026, another average increase of 16.3% is locked in, and one of the state's familiar names is going away. Here is how three ordinary self-employed households should think it through. The people are examples, not clients.

First, the rules all three share

Quick answer: For 2027 coverage the credit ends above about $63,840 for one person, $86,560 for two, $109,280 for three and $132,000 for four. Ohio uses HealthCare.gov, open enrollment runs November 1 to January 15, and December 15 is the cutoff for a January 1 start.

The test uses modified adjusted gross income and is settled on the tax return. From the 2026 tax year forward, a household that takes advance credits and finishes over the line repays all of them. And CareSource has filed to discontinue its individual plans in Ohio effective January 1, 2027, affecting 28,319 people as of late May, almost all of them on the exchange. AmeriHealth Caritas is new to the Ohio Marketplace for 2027.

Household 1: a freelance developer in Columbus, 34, healthy

She earns well over the single-person line and has no prescriptions and no ongoing care. On the Marketplace she is paying for a risk pool that is older and sicker than she is.

What she should price: a Bronze plan on the Marketplace, which since 2026 qualifies for a health savings account, and a medically underwritten private plan. The private plan asks health questions and prices her on the answers. If she is approved at a standard rate, it will usually be the lower premium, often with a nationwide PPO network that suits someone who works from wherever her clients are.

What she has to accept: the private plan is not ACA coverage. Benefits depend on the plan, and maternity is the one she should ask about directly if a family is in her five-year picture. If it is, the Marketplace Bronze plan with an HSA is the safer base.

Household 2: a Dayton couple, both 52, on a CareSource plan

He runs an HVAC business and she keeps the books. Their plan ends December 31 no matter what they do. HealthCare.gov will suggest a replacement from another carrier at the same metal level.

What they should do first: ignore the suggested plan until they have checked two things, their doctors and their prescriptions, against it and against every other carrier selling in Montgomery County. Carrier averages for 2027 run from single digits to above 20%, so the ranking in their county has probably changed.

What they should price next: at 52, the Marketplace premium for two is the largest fixed bill many self-employed couples have. If both are healthy, underwritten pricing can look very different at this age, and it is worth one phone call to find out. If either of them takes maintenance medication for something like blood pressure or cholesterol, that goes on the application and may change the offer. Better to learn that in November than in January.

What they should not do: wait for the January bill. Past December 15 a new Marketplace plan starts February 1, and their CareSource coverage will already have ended.

Household 3: a Cleveland contractor, his wife and two kids, one with Type 1 diabetes

Income is over the four-person line. The parents and one child are healthy. The other child needs insulin, supplies and an endocrinologist.

The honest answer: that child belongs on a Marketplace plan. It must cover the condition from the first day, it cannot charge more for it, and it has an out-of-pocket limit. No underwritten plan will do those three things for a condition that already exists.

The part families miss: the household does not have to be on one policy. Some families keep the child who needs guaranteed coverage on a Marketplace plan and price the healthy members separately. It can lower the total, and it also means two deductibles and two sets of paperwork, so run both versions before deciding. The family is still one tax household for the credit test either way.

The income question: a family just over $132,000 should ask a tax professional whether retirement and HSA contributions would bring them under. With a child who uses a lot of care, a credit plus a richer plan is worth more to them than to either of the other households.

Two Ohio details worth knowing

  • Short-term plans top out at 364 days here. Ohio's rule predates the federal back-and-forth, and some insurers stop at four or six months. A short-term plan excludes pre-existing conditions, so it is a bridge for Household 1, not a plan for Household 3.
  • Ohio Farm Bureau now offers member health plans. Ohio is one of the states that passed a law in 2025 allowing them. They are medically underwritten and are not insurance under state law, so the same questions apply as with any plan that can decline you.

Key Takeaway

Above the line in Ohio, the right answer follows your health and your carrier, not your income. Healthy and mobile points one way, a departing carrier forces a fresh look, and one ongoing condition anchors that person to the Marketplace.

Ohio questions readers send us

Is CareSource leaving Ohio's Marketplace in 2027?

Yes. CareSource filed to discontinue its individual market plans in Ohio effective January 1, 2027, with coverage ending December 31, 2026. About 28,000 Ohioans were enrolled as of late May 2026.

How much are Ohio individual health insurance rates rising in 2027?

The final average for unsubsidized individual market enrollees is about 16.3%, following an average of 19.8% for 2026. Individual carriers vary widely.

Can part of a family be on the Marketplace and part on a private plan?

Yes. Family members can hold different policies. Members with health conditions usually belong on a Marketplace plan, which must cover them, while healthy members can be priced on an underwritten plan. The household is still counted together for the tax credit income test.

How long can a short-term health plan last in Ohio?

Up to 364 days in total under Ohio's rules, and some insurers limit their plans to four or six months. Short-term plans generally exclude pre-existing conditions.

What income is over the subsidy line in Ohio for 2027?

About $63,840 for a single person, $86,560 for two, $109,280 for three and $132,000 for four, based on 400% of the 2026 federal poverty guideline.

Which household are you closest to?

Tell us who needs coverage and where you live. A licensed Ohio broker on our team works out which lanes fit and sends quotes by the next business day. One broker, and your details are never sold.