Earn Too Much for a Subsidy in Florida? Here Are Your Real Options for 2027

The most common Florida phone call we get in the fall starts the same way: "My renewal says I owe the full premium now, and I'm not sick. What am I supposed to do?" The person on the line is usually a contractor, a Realtor, a consultant, or a couple running a small business, and they have just discovered that the tax credit that made their plan affordable is gone because their income crossed a line. This article is the answer we give them, written down.

Where the cliff actually sits

From 2021 through 2025, a temporary rule capped what anyone had to pay for a benchmark plan at 8.5% of income, no matter how much they earned. That rule expired on December 31, 2025, and Congress did not renew it. The original ACA math came back: credits phase down as income rises and then vanish completely at 400% of the federal poverty level.

The numbers move each year with the poverty guidelines. Marketplace eligibility for a given plan year uses the guideline published early the year before, so 2027 coverage keys off the 2026 figures: $15,960 for one person and $33,000 for a family of four, which puts the 400% line at about $63,840 and $132,000. Add roughly $22,720 to the family line for each additional household member. The figure that matters is modified adjusted gross income, not gross receipts, which is why the fourth lane below exists.

Why Florida feels it more than almost any other state

Florida runs on the individual market in a way most states do not. Only about 40% of Floridians get coverage through an employer, the lowest share in the country, and more than one in five residents under 65 buys on the Marketplace. The state never expanded Medicaid, so there is no safety net just below the credit range either. When the enhanced credits lapsed, Florida lost about 450,000 effectuated enrollees between 2025 and 2026, the biggest drop of any state, while premiums nationally rose an average of 37%.

Florida's 2026 rates rose 31.5% on average, and the proposed 2027 increases add another 15.3% unweighted, with filings ranging from under 4% to over 39% depending on the carrier. If you are above the credit line, you are paying every point of that yourself.

Lane 1: full-price Marketplace

It is worth stating the obvious: a full-price ACA plan is still a good plan. It covers pre-existing conditions, it caps your out-of-pocket exposure, and nobody can decline you. The problem for a healthy household is purely price. If you go this route, shop the whole county menu rather than auto-renewing, because carrier lineups changed for 2027 (Cigna left the Marketplace entirely and Sunshine State members are moving to Ambetter), and bronze HSA-eligible plans let you deduct contributions on top of the premium.

Lane 2: a medically underwritten private plan

This is the lane the Marketplace never shows you, and it is the reason a healthy self-employed household above the credit line should not sign a full-price renewal without a second quote. In Florida we quote underwritten plans from carriers we are appointed with, including USHEALTH Group's SecureAdvantage and PremierAdvantage products, and we run them side by side with the Marketplace number for your county.

Read the exclusions before you fall in love with the premium. These plans are typically organized around sickness and accident coverage with a network, a deductible, and add-on riders. Maternity, pre-existing conditions, and certain treatments may be limited or excluded, and the application is a legal document, so answer it completely. We walk through the health questions on the phone rather than on a web form, and if the answers say you are not a fit, we tell you and go back to lane one.

Lane 3: a short-term bridge

Florida allows short-term medical plans with initial terms under 12 months and total duration up to 36 months through renewals, and the federal four-month cap has not been enforced since August 2025. That makes a short-term plan a legitimate bridge when you are between jobs, waiting on a start date, or outside open enrollment without a qualifying event. It is not a substitute for a full year of real coverage: pre-existing conditions are generally excluded and benefits are limited. Our short-term guide for Florida covers the details.

Lane 4: the income side

Because the 400% line is a cliff, the value of dropping below it can be thousands of dollars in credits for a few thousand dollars of retirement savings you would arguably want to make anyway. The trap is estimating too low: the credit is reconciled on your tax return, and if your actual income lands above the line, the full advance credit is repaid. Self-employed income swings, so be conservative and update your Marketplace application mid-year if the business takes off.

How to decide in an afternoon

• Pin down household MAGI for 2027 with your tax preparer, including any retirement or HSA contributions you can commit to.
• If you will land under the line, the Marketplace with the credit almost always wins. We will help you enroll for free and say so plainly.
• If you will land over it and everyone is healthy, get the underwritten quote and the full-price Marketplace quote for your county on the same day, then compare premium, deductible, network, and exclusions, not premium alone.
• If someone has a condition, skip underwriting and shop the Marketplace menu hard, because carriers and networks changed for 2027.
• If your problem is timing, bridge it with short-term and set a calendar reminder for the next enrollment window.

That is the whole decision. If you want one licensed Florida broker to run all four lanes for your ZIP code and household, start on our Florida self-employed page. One call, real numbers, and your information is never sold.

Questions Florida readers ask about this